| Oscar Nominations | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ceremony | Film | Category | Role | Result |
| 96th Academy Awards Oscars 2024 |
Killers of the Flower Moon | Actor in a Supporting Role | "William Hale" | Nominated |
| 92nd Academy Awards Oscars 2020 |
The Irishman | Best Picture | Producer | Nominated |
| 85th Academy Awards Oscars 2013 |
Silver Linings Playbook | Actor in a Supporting Role | "Pat Sr." | Nominated |
| 64th Academy Awards Oscars 1992 |
Cape Fear | Actor in a Leading Role | "Max Cady" | Nominated |
| 63rd Academy Awards Oscars 1991 |
Awakenings | Actor in a Leading Role | "Leonard Lowe" | Nominated |
| 53rd Academy Awards Oscars 1981 |
Raging Bull | Actor in a Leading Role | "Jake LaMotta" | Won |
| 51st Academy Awards Oscars 1979 |
The Deer Hunter | Actor in a Leading Role | "Michael" | Nominated |
| 49th Academy Awards Oscars 1977 |
Taxi Driver | Actor in a Leading Role | "Travis Bickle" | Nominated |
| 47th Academy Awards Oscars 1975 |
The Godfather Part II | Actor in a Supporting Role | "Vito Corleone" | Won |